A federal appeals court has just delivered another major setback to a House Democrat trying to stop a criminal case tied to an alleged confrontation with ICE officers.

The lawmaker is Rep. LaMonica McIver of New Jersey, and the Third Circuit has refused to rehear her bid to dismiss the charges.

The November 19 order leaves intact an August ruling that allowed two federal counts against McIver to move forward.

That means her attempt to use constitutional legislative immunity to block the prosecution has failed again.

The court’s latest decision was reported Friday:

ADVERTISEMENT

The case dates back to a May 9, 2025 visit to the Delaney Hall federal immigration facility in Newark.

McIver and two other members of Congress went to the facility for an oversight inspection as an immigration protest was taking place outside.

Newark Mayor Ras Baraka was also present. Federal officers moved to arrest him after officials said he entered a secured area and refused repeated directions to leave.

According to the Justice Department’s account of the indictment, McIver tried to prevent officers from completing that arrest after the congressional delegation’s oversight visit coincided with a protest outside Delaney Hall and federal officials ordered Baraka to leave the secured area. The department says officers warned the mayor several times, members of the delegation challenged his removal, and McIver then joined others around him before allegedly using her forearm against one federal officer, grabbing that officer, and later striking a second officer as agents worked through the crowd.

Prosecutors allege she drove her forearm into one officer, grabbed him, and later struck another officer with both forearms.

The government says someone in the crowd yelled for people to “circle the mayor” as agents made a second effort to take Baraka into custody outside the secured area.

McIver allegedly faced Baraka, placed her arms around him and joined others in blocking officers from handcuffing him.

The indictment charges her under the federal law that prohibits forcibly assaulting, resisting, opposing, impeding, intimidating or interfering with designated federal officers while they perform official duties.

Those remain allegations. McIver has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

ADVERTISEMENT

The first two counts each carry a maximum penalty of eight years in prison, while a third count carries up to one year.

McIver asked the courts to throw out the case, arguing that her actions were protected by the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause because she was performing congressional oversight.

A divided Third Circuit panel rejected that argument as to the first two counts in August.

The majority drew a sharp line between conducting oversight and the physical conduct alleged in the indictment.

In its August 26 opinion, the court concluded that pushing past and forcibly striking someone are not legislative acts protected by congressional immunity, even when the alleged conduct occurs during a visit connected to Congress’s oversight responsibilities. The majority examined the specific acts charged rather than labeling everything that happened during the inspection as legislative work, allowed Counts One and Two to proceed, sent the broader third count back for additional district-court review, and dismissed the immediate appeal of McIver’s selective and vindictive prosecution claims for lack of appellate jurisdiction at that stage.

The panel sent the broader third count back to the district court for additional review, but it allowed the two central counts to continue.

Judge Cindy Chung wrote the majority opinion, joined by Judge Stephanos Bibas. The court examined the specific conduct charged rather than treating every act during an oversight visit as automatically legislative.

The majority said prosecuting the first two counts would not require McIver to answer for any protected legislative act, even though the confrontation occurred during a visit connected to congressional oversight.

Judge Thomas Ambro agreed that the first count could proceed but dissented in part. He would have required more factual development on the second count and allowed additional inquiry into McIver’s claims of selective or vindictive prosecution.

ADVERTISEMENT

That divided ruling supplied the legal foundation the full court has now declined to revisit.

McIver then sought rehearing from the original panel and the full appeals court.

The one-page November 19 order denied McIver’s requests for both panel rehearing and review by the full court, leaving the August opinion in place without adding a new discussion of the constitutional issues or the factual record. The order says no judge who joined the original decision requested rehearing and a majority of the active judges did not vote to take the case en banc, while identifying Restrepo, Krause and Montgomery-Reeves as the three judges who would have granted the petition and noting that senior Judge Ambro’s vote was limited to panel rehearing.

No judge who joined the original decision asked to rehear the case, and a majority of the active judges did not vote for full-court review.

Three judges—L. Felipe Restrepo, Cheryl Ann Krause and Tamika Montgomery-Reeves—voted to grant rehearing.

Judge Ambro, who participated in the original panel as a senior judge, was eligible to vote only on panel rehearing and not on whether the entire active court should take the case.

The order did not offer a new explanation of the constitutional issues or revisit the evidence. Instead, it left the August majority opinion in place as the controlling appellate decision.

That procedural posture matters because McIver has now exhausted the ordinary rehearing route inside the Third Circuit.

Unless the Supreme Court intervenes, the case returns to the district court with the first two counts intact and the third count awaiting the additional review ordered by the panel.

ADVERTISEMENT

McIver answered the ruling by accusing President Donald Trump’s Justice Department of weaponizing the prosecution against her.

She posted her response on X:

In a statement from her congressional office, McIver said her lawyers were considering every available next step and framed the prosecution as an attempt by the Trump administration to punish a member of Congress for inspecting an immigration facility. Her office called the ruling harmful to congressional oversight, emphasized that she remains the only lawmaker facing criminal penalties from the Delaney Hall confrontation, repeated that she could face up to 17 years if convicted on all counts, and urged supporters to view the case as a broader warning about executive power rather than an ordinary prosecution over alleged physical conduct.

She also claimed she faces prison because she “dared to do” oversight of ICE.

Her office framed the case as a test of whether the executive branch can punish lawmakers for inspecting federal detention facilities and argued that the decision weakens congressional oversight protections.

McIver said the ruling moves the country closer to a situation in which a president can imprison political opponents, and she urged supporters of her position to stand with her as the prosecution continues.

The statement also emphasized that she is the only member of Congress facing criminal penalties from the Delaney Hall confrontation and repeated her claim that the charges are unjust.

Those arguments remain central to McIver’s public defense, but the appellate court has distinguished her official inspection from the alleged physical acts charged by prosecutors.

The court’s ruling does not decide whether McIver committed the alleged acts. It decides that her status as a member of Congress does not automatically shield the charged conduct from prosecution.

Fellow New Jersey Democrat Rep. Rob Menendez quickly rallied to McIver’s defense:

That political defense does not change the legal reality: McIver has now lost at the district court, before a three-judge appellate panel, and in her request for the full Third Circuit to reconsider the matter.

Her remaining options could include asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review the immunity ruling while the criminal case continues in New Jersey.

The latest order is brief, but its consequence is significant.

Members of Congress have broad constitutional protection for genuine legislative work. The Third Circuit has now repeatedly refused to stretch that protection over the physical conduct alleged in this case.

This is a Guest Post from our friends over at WLTReport. View the original article here.

 

Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.