President Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the Navy permanently called eight reported sailor suicide attempts “suicide mitigations” during a confirmation hearing—and senators did not let him slide past it.

Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao made the remark Tuesday while senators pressed him about the brutal strain of extended deployments, food problems and mental-health emergencies aboard ships supporting the war with Iran.

“You see it as eight suicide attempts. I see it as eight suicide mitigations,” Cao told Sen. Mark Kelly, D-Ariz., during the hearing; he argued that counselors and mental-health specialists aboard the ships had prevented deaths.

Kelly, a retired Navy captain, answered with the point that mattered: The Navy should not have conditions in which sailors want to end their lives in the first place.

The Associated Press reported that Cao acknowledged the Iran war is straining Navy resources as senators from both parties questioned him about lengthy ship deployments, depleted weapons stockpiles and conditions faced by sailors, while also examining whether the military can sustain its current operations without sacrificing its ability to respond elsewhere. Cao is a retired Navy captain and combat veteran who has served as acting secretary, but his bid for the permanent civilian post requires Congress to waive a federal waiting-period law because he left active duty less than seven years ago, turning the hearing into a direct test of whether the man seeking to run the service understands what sailors have endured and can speak honestly about the human cost of the mission.

ADVERTISEMENT

Cao’s wording immediately became the defining moment of that test.

Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y., also confronted Cao over the phrase and told him not to call attempted suicides “mitigations.” When Cao disputed that a sailor who went overboard had been trying to die, Gillibrand fired back by asking what the sailor had been trying to do—“swim to Guam?”

That exchange stripped away the bureaucratic language. A sailor going overboard during an extraordinarily long deployment is not a public-relations problem to be rebranded; it is a warning flare.

Navy Times detailed how the hearing ranged beyond that clash to prolonged deployments, mental-health resources and the Navy’s failure to notify Congress promptly after the removal of three senior leaders aboard the USS South Dakota. Cao said there was no excuse for that communication failure and promised procedures that would keep lawmakers informed without publicly destroying the careers of sailors involved in an unfinished investigation.

The report also said Cao defended the Navy’s response to the Lincoln strike group’s mental-health crisis by emphasizing the counselors and specialists available aboard ship, while senators pressed him on the conditions surrounding the incidents and the service’s responsibility to its people. Those resources matter, but they do not erase the emergency: Eight sailors reaching the point of an apparent suicide attempt is not proof that the system worked, and senior leaders still must confront the deployment length, morale and living conditions that pushed sailors toward a breaking point.

Sen. Andy Kim, D-N.J., called Cao’s statement disqualifying and pointed to another line Cao has used about wanting service members to be tough enough to “rip out their own guts, eat them and ask for seconds.”

Cao’s own Senate Armed Services Committee opening statement described leadership as a responsibility to ensure sailors and Marines are properly trained, equipped and ready for combat, while invoking his refugee story, decades of Navy service and belief that America’s sea services must remain lethal and prepared. Those are serious credentials and goals, but they make his later wording harder to excuse: A secretary can demand toughness without treating attempted suicide like a semantic win, because readiness depends on people and people cannot be reduced to an after-action statistic when the conditions of deployment have pushed them toward self-destruction.

Republicans may still decide Cao’s record and experience outweigh this hearing. But if they confirm him, they should demand a clear answer about what changes aboard these ships—and how quickly.

The Navy does not need a cleverer label for sailors in crisis. It needs leaders who hear the alarm.

ADVERTISEMENT

 

Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.