Well, now we know.
Before Zohran Mamdani became mayor and moved to dismantle the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, that very unit had already hauled him away in zip ties.
Not once.
Twice.
Archival photographs and video from two separate protests show officers wearing SRG insignia taking Mamdani into custody years before he reached City Hall.
Mayor Mamdani was arrested at least twice by elite NYPD unit he’s controversially disbanding https://t.co/8dTjnMDb3h pic.twitter.com/BMqa7hUVsw
— California Post (@californiapost) November 20, 2026
The New York Post traced the first documented encounter to August 19, 2021, when Mamdani was a state assemblyman. He joined a Downtown Brooklyn protest demanding that lawmakers return to Albany and extend New York’s eviction moratorium.
Mamdani and Assemblywoman Marcela Mitaynes were among 17 people taken into custody. Video Mamdani later shared shows him zip-tied as an officer wearing the SRG patch escorts him away, and contemporaneous local reporting says he was released several hours later from an East New York precinct.
Three years later, the same unit appears in the record again.
On June 17, 2024, Mamdani joined tenant activists outside Hunter College as the Rent Guidelines Board prepared to vote on another increase for rent-stabilized apartments. A tenant-coalition release recorded that Mamdani and Councilwoman Alexa Aviles joined demonstrators blocking the doors and risking arrest.
ABC7 footage from that scene shows an officer with clear SRG markings leading Mamdani away with his hands bound behind his back. Both arrests grew out of protest actions rather than counterterrorism investigations, underscoring how deeply the unit had moved into crowd control.
Mayor Mamdani was arrested at least twice by elite NYPD unit he’s controversially disbanding https://t.co/lDCwdfjKQW pic.twitter.com/oGz9Y16tjy
— New York Post (@nypost) November 20, 2026
The photographs do not prove that personal animus motivated Mamdani’s policy. They do establish that his argument over the SRG was grounded in direct encounters with officers from the unit, not a distant debate he discovered after entering City Hall.
Mamdani has been arrested at other demonstrations over the years. These two episodes stand apart because archival footage ties them directly to the Strategic Response Group he later promised voters he would dismantle.
He announced the breakup on November 16 alongside NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, making good on one of his central campaign promises. The official argument is that protest response and counterterrorism should never have lived inside the same unit.
The ABC7 New York report makes clear that the announcement does not erase the NYPD’s counterterrorism capability. The SRG’s roughly 500 highly trained officers will be reassigned, with many moving into the Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau.
The unit is scheduled to dissolve in spring 2027, after a transition period rather than overnight. Tisch said the department’s response to genuine crowd-control emergencies will remain familiar to New Yorkers, and trained officers will still be able to make arrests when civil disobedience crosses the legal line.
The city is splitting the SRG’s former jobs among several commands.
Counterterrorism work, including heavy-weapons deployments, will move to the existing counterterrorism bureau. Other officers will enter a Patrol Support Division and spend most of their time on ordinary patrol while keeping specialized crowd-management training.
An official Mayor’s Office transcript lays out the protest side of the plan. A 30-officer First Amendment Support Team will focus on communication and de-escalation during the transition, while a civilian-led Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division is built inside the Office of Community Safety.
Those civilians will carry no weapons and have no arrest powers. Mamdani said their work will begin before demonstrations, with organizers and community leaders, and continue through the early stages of a march or rally.
Once violence begins, civilians will not be expected to hold the line.
Mamdani said uniformed police will remain present whenever a protest turns violent. He also said the new civilian division is not scheduled to launch fully until 2028, leaving the NYPD’s First Amendment team responsible during the transition.
CBS New York documented the sharp disagreement over whether those safeguards are enough. Police Benevolent Association President Patrick Hendry warned that the decision puts both public safety and officer safety at risk.
Former NYPD detective Dave Sarni said the city could be opening the door to people who want to cause harm or destroy property. Councilman Phil Wong argued that the specialized unit remains necessary for major incidents and street disorder.
Civil-liberties groups celebrated the change, citing years of complaints about aggressive protest tactics. The overhaul also bars long guns and pepper spray as crowd-management tools, while the city says tear gas and kettling had already been discontinued after the 2020 George Floyd protests.
Tisch insists the reorganization strengthens the department rather than weakening it. Her officers will retain the force, training, and command structure needed for serious threats; the fight is over which situations should trigger that response and who should meet peaceful protesters first.
Mamdani’s allies call the breakup a civil-liberties victory.
His critics see something else: a mayor dismantling the exact police unit that twice placed him in zip ties when his activism crossed into arrestable civil disobedience.
There is no public evidence that personal revenge drove the decision, and Mamdani campaigned openly on separating protest policing from counterterrorism.
Still, the history matters.
New Yorkers now know that Mamdani lived this fight years before he carried it into City Hall.
It was personal experience.
And when the mayor says the old SRG model had to go, he is talking about a unit whose officers once closed their hands around his wrists.
This is a Guest Post from our friends over at WLTReport. View the original article here.







