New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani had a rare gift on the Fourth of July weekend. He got to speak from George Washington’s own desk, on the eve of America’s 250th birthday, and say almost anything he wanted about the country.

He chose to spend most of it telling Americans what is wrong with America.

Now rabbis are pushing back, and their objection is not that a mayor cannot criticize his country. It is that he picked the worst possible moment to do it.

Fox News reported that Mamdani delivered the immigration-themed America 250 speech ahead of the holiday weekend while flanked by eight recently naturalized citizens.

He opened by invoking the Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island, and the immigrant story before pivoting hard into a list of grievances against modern America.

ADVERTISEMENT

Fox said he went after ICE agents, describing masked agents terrorizing streets and hauling people away in unmarked vans after eating food cooked by undocumented neighbors. He hit oligarchs buying elections, monopolies, bombs, bailouts, and the health insurance industry.

He also referenced children going to sleep hungry while the “world’s first trillionaire” hungers for more. Fox connected that line to Elon Musk following the SpaceX IPO, while noting Mamdani did not name him in that line.

The setting was the part that made it sting.

NBC New York reported that Mamdani gave the address from the desk George Washington used during his presidency, now housed at New York City Hall.

That desk originally sat in Federal Hall, the nation’s first capitol in lower Manhattan.

NBC said the mayor spoke hours before President Trump’s national America 250 address, surrounded by naturalized citizens, and framed New York City as a symbolic gateway in America’s story. The local report said the speech spotlighted Indigenous people, enslaved Africans, and immigrants while casting the country as a place of contradictions still working toward its founding ideals.

A speech about America’s contradictions is fair game most days of the year. Rabbis argued that America’s birthday, from the desk of the first president, is not most days.

JNS reported on July 6 that rabbis across the Jewish community sharply criticized the remarks over their timing and context.

The report said Rabbi David Wolpe, rabbi emeritus of Sinai Temple in Los Angeles, called one of Mamdani’s comments unusually thoughtless and self-sabotaging.

ADVERTISEMENT

JNS also quoted Rabbi Menachem Levine, CEO of a Chicago Orthodox school, who compared Mamdani’s rhetorical method to the biblical spies episode. Begin with praise for the land, then pivot the audience toward fear, grievance, and rejection.

The comparison was pointed on purpose. In the biblical account, the spies returned from the Holy Land, acknowledged its good qualities, then frightened the Israelites so badly that the nation was condemned to 40 years of wandering in the desert.

The rabbis’ larger point was not that national self-criticism is forbidden. It was that timing and context matter, and a 250th birthday is the wrong slot for a broad indictment of the country.

That argument came with a calendar.

The point being made there is that Jewish tradition never banned national self-criticism. It gave it a designated day, Tisha B’Av, when Jews sit on the floor and read the catalogue of their own failures out loud.

Because that day exists, the rest of the calendar does not have to carry the indictment.

Mamdani had the whole year to list what he thinks is broken in America. He put it on the birthday instead, from Washington’s desk, in front of new citizens who just chose this country.

Plenty of Americans managed to celebrate the 250th without a lecture about oligarchs and unmarked vans. The mayor of the nation’s largest city could not, and the rabbis noticed.

This is a Guest Post from our friends over at WLTReport. View the original article here.

ADVERTISEMENT
 

Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.