Texas just delivered the kind of election result Republicans will be dissecting for years.

Democrat James Talarico defeated Republican Ken Paxton in the U.S. Senate race, ending the GOP’s decades-long grip on statewide elections and turning one of America’s reddest political prizes into a flashing warning sign.

This was not a close call that can be explained away by one bad precinct or a late ballot dump. Republicans lost a Senate seat in a state President Trump carried by nearly 14 points only two years ago.

Talarico celebrated the result in the bluntest possible terms.

The Associated Press reported that the 37-year-old state legislator and former middle-school teacher became the first Democrat to win statewide office in Texas in more than 30 years. He will also become the youngest member of the U.S. Senate.

ADVERTISEMENT

The result helped Democrats retake the Senate and exposed a Republican failure that was visible long before Election Day. GOP leaders warned that Paxton’s legal, personal and ethical baggage could put a safe seat in danger, but the party nominated him after a bitter primary against longtime Senator John Cornyn.

Paxton had survived impeachment by the Republican-controlled Texas House, a state Senate trial that ended in acquittal and years of controversy surrounding his office and personal life. Those issues followed him into a general election where Republicans needed a disciplined campaign and got a referendum on their own candidate instead.

The warning is not complicated: loyalty cannot replace electability, and a red-state label cannot rescue a campaign that gives skeptical voters too many reasons to stay home or cross the aisle.

Talarico’s campaign framed the victory as a revolt against the state’s political establishment.

Axios noted that Talarico’s win ends a 38-year Democratic drought in Texas Senate elections and the nation’s longest Democratic drought in statewide contests. The race also became the most expensive Senate battle in the country after Paxton defeated Cornyn in the Republican runoff.

Talarico ran as a former teacher and Presbyterian seminarian focused on affordability, public education and opposition to wealthy political donors. That softer presentation helped him sell a far more progressive record to voters who were angry about prices, corruption and the direction of the state.

Republicans cannot afford to confuse packaging with policy. Talarico has supported radical positions on gender, abortion and the role of government, and he will now have six years in Washington to act on them.

The campaign’s victory speech made clear that Democrats intend to turn this win into a national model.

The Daily Wire reported that Talarico built a coalition of young, independent, black and Hispanic voters while outperforming expectations in suburban Fort Worth and in Denton and Collin counties. The outlet also pointed to the political damage created by Paxton’s bruising primary and the enormous sums Republican leaders spent attacking him before trying to unite behind him.

ADVERTISEMENT

The voter data is brutal for the GOP. AP’s survey of more than 5,000 Texas Senate voters found that roughly three-quarters of voters under 30 backed Talarico, along with about six in ten Hispanic voters.

Republicans had made real gains with both groups during President Trump’s campaigns. Watching those gains collapse in a midterm should trigger honest evaluation, not another round of consultants insisting the fundamentals remain fine.

Texas is too important to the conservative movement and too important to the presidential map for denial. Democrats won more than one office; they proved that a combination of candidate weakness, economic frustration and disciplined messaging can break through even where the GOP believed it had a permanent advantage.

The answer is not to imitate Democrats. It is to nominate credible conservatives, deliver measurable results and speak directly to the voters who no longer assume the Republican label is enough.

Texas has sent the warning. Republicans can learn from it now, or learn it again when the stakes are even higher.

 

Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.