President Trump’s nominee to lead the nation’s cyber-defense agency ran into a bipartisan Senate roadblock Thursday after one confirmation-hearing answer prompted both a Republican and a Democrat to announce holds on his nomination.

Michael LoSapio was supposed to be the man who finally ended a nearly two-year leadership vacancy at the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency.

Now his path to confirmation has become much harder—and the calendar is working against him.

LoSapio appeared before the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee on Thursday. He is Palantir’s chief information security officer and President Trump’s nominee to run CISA, the federal agency responsible for helping defend critical infrastructure, federal networks and election systems from cyber threats.

The hearing turned sharply when Sen. Richard Blumenthal asked LoSapio whether the Capitol was attacked on January 6, 2021.

ADVERTISEMENT

LoSapio said he did not believe it was an attack. He also declined to identify the winner of the 2020 presidential election, saying he would not answer a question about an election held six years ago.

Those answers immediately became the story.

The Senate Homeland Security Committee identifies LoSapio as the nominee for CISA director and retains both the hearing video and his prepared statement. The official record shows that he appeared in a crowded nomination panel alongside candidates for the Government Accountability Office, Office of Government Ethics and several inspectors-general posts.

In his written testimony, LoSapio thanked President Trump for the nomination and described a career built around real-world cyber incidents, private-sector security and emergency response. He told senators that CISA must defend federal systems and critical infrastructure while helping state, local and private partners prepare for attacks.

That background is the reason the White House chose him. It also raises the stakes of a confirmation fight that now threatens to leave the agency’s top job vacant even longer.

That résumé is substantial. But Senate confirmations are also votes, and two senators quickly made clear that LoSapio had lost the fast lane.

Nextgov/FCW reported that Republican Sen. Thom Tillis and Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden separately planned to place holds on the nomination. Tillis’s opposition matters because Republicans have only a short lame-duck window before Democrats take control of the Senate in January.

A Senate hold does not automatically kill a nomination. It does prevent leaders from moving the matter quickly by unanimous consent, forcing them to spend scarce floor time and assemble the votes for a longer process.

The nomination can still move, but only by consuming time Senate leaders may need for other nominees and legislation.

ADVERTISEMENT

That is a serious problem when the Senate is trying to process a long list of nominees before the current Congress ends.

If the nomination remains pending when Congress adjourns, President Trump would have to submit it again. A new Democratic Senate would then control whether LoSapio receives another hearing or vote, making delay itself a potentially decisive weapon.

The Associated Press reported that LoSapio’s answer came during questioning about election security and the violence at the Capitol. AP also noted that CISA was created during President Trump’s first term and protects targets ranging from banks and dams to nuclear facilities and voting systems.

The political charge around CISA is not new.

The agency became a conservative flash point after the 2020 election because of its role in election-security communications and its contacts with technology companies. Republicans have demanded that CISA focus on hard cybersecurity and critical infrastructure instead of becoming a federal referee for political speech.

That reform mission is legitimate. It is also one reason the agency needs a confirmed leader who can defend a clear mission under hostile questioning without turning one answer into the entire hearing.

LoSapio’s defenders can fairly argue that Blumenthal was trying to drag the nomination into a six-year-old political fight. Democrats were never going to give a Trump cyber nominee a gentle hearing.

But Tillis is not a Democrat. His planned hold converts the problem from predictable partisan outrage into a genuine confirmation obstacle.

The White House now faces a practical decision: spend precious Senate time trying to push LoSapio through, find a way to satisfy the Republican hold, or accept that the nomination may have to be resubmitted to a Democratic-controlled Senate.

ADVERTISEMENT

None of those options is easy.

President Trump nominated a cybersecurity executive to rebuild an agency that badly needs disciplined leadership. One answer did not erase LoSapio’s professional experience.

It did, however, change the math in the Senate.

That is the hard truth: in a confirmation fight, the answer you wish had remained a footnote can become the only answer anyone remembers.

 

Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.