Well, there it is.

The Justice Department is walking away from its civil fight to stop Alaska from certifying Democrat Mary Peltola as the winner of the state’s U.S. Senate race.

Dropping the civil case does not clear Peltola or shut down the separate criminal investigation into the alleged “Decoy Dan” operation.

The Justice Department told the Ninth Circuit on November 19 that the civil case had become moot after the ballots were counted and Peltola finished with a majority.

DOJ asked the appeals court to vacate the lower-court order and send the case back for dismissal on mootness grounds. In other words, the department is ending its attempt to stop certification while still trying to erase the district judge’s earlier ruling from the books.

That is an important distinction.

ADVERTISEMENT

DOJ did not concede that the underlying allegations were fabricated, and it did not ask the appellate court to endorse the district court’s reasoning. It said the requested investigation of voter confusion could no longer produce a different election result.

The numbers boxed the government in.

According to the Alaska Division of Elections, the November 18 count remained officially labeled “unofficial” while the state prepared for its November 25 certification target. The official results page said the final regional count of absentee and questioned ballots had been completed, but certification had not yet occurred.

Peltola had already crossed the outright-majority threshold. That meant Alaska did not need additional ranked-choice rounds to determine the winner, and the votes received by the second candidate named Dan Sullivan were not enough to erase her lead.

The state listed two different Sullivans on the ballot: Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan and independent candidate Daniel Sullivan.

The ballot identified them with different middle initials and party labels, but the shared first and last names became the basis of DOJ’s voter-confusion theory.

That second name was the heart of the entire controversy.

President Trump and Republican allies alleged that Democratic operatives helped recruit Daniel Sullivan as a same-name spoiler designed to confuse voters and siphon support away from the incumbent senator.

Peltola has denied involvement.

The Justice Department originally sued Alaska on October 22 and sought an order preventing certification if the incumbent lost by a margin small enough for the second Sullivan’s votes to matter.

ADVERTISEMENT

The department argued that an investigation was needed to determine whether voters had accidentally selected the wrong Sullivan.

Federal Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the amended complaint on November 1.

In the district court order, Gleason concluded that the federal government had not shown standing and that the court lacked a workable way to grant the requested relief while preserving ballot secrecy. DOJ had asked to isolate ballots involving the second Sullivan so investigators could determine whether voters selected him by mistake.

The ruling did not decide whether Democratic operatives recruited the second Sullivan. It rejected DOJ’s proposed civil remedy, granted the defendants’ dismissal motions, and dismissed the amended complaint without prejudice.

The government appealed to the Ninth Circuit, seeking to preserve its ability to stop certification if the alleged confusion could have changed the winner.

Then the November 18 vote count produced the outcome that made the certification case collapse: Peltola’s majority exceeded any possible effect from the second Sullivan’s total.

Peltola declared victory and immediately began presenting the result as a mandate from Alaska voters.

For conservatives, that victory post does not answer the harder question of how the second Dan Sullivan reached the ballot or who may have helped put him there.

It only shows why the certification lawsuit no longer had a practical path forward.

ADVERTISEMENT

If Peltola had won by fewer votes than independent candidate Daniel Sullivan received, DOJ could have argued that alleged voter confusion might have changed the result.

Once her lead exceeded that universe of disputed votes, the requested pre-certification investigation could not deliver a different winner.

That does not make the alleged recruitment operation acceptable.

It makes the civil lawsuit moot.

And that is where much of the early reporting has blurred two very different legal tracks.

The Washington Examiner reported on November 18 that DOJ had issued more than 200 subpoenas in a separate criminal investigation into the alleged recruitment effort, citing a law-enforcement official.

That investigation spans multiple states and has included target letters and demands for records, according to the report. No criminal charge has been announced, and receiving a subpoena or target letter is not proof that anyone committed a crime.

Nothing in DOJ’s November 19 appellate filing dismisses that criminal probe.

The department’s civil lawyers are ending a lawsuit over certification because the election math made the requested relief meaningless. Criminal investigators can still examine whether anyone violated federal law while organizing, funding, or concealing the alleged spoiler effort.

ADVERTISEMENT


 

The public should also be precise about what has and has not been proven.

There are serious allegations about a coordinated attempt to manipulate the field of candidates. There is an ongoing investigation, but there has not been a criminal conviction establishing that Peltola or her campaign committed fraud.

The second Sullivan was legally placed on the ballot after the Alaska Supreme Court allowed his candidacy to proceed.

The ultimate vote count also indicates that his candidacy did not determine the winner.

Those facts can all be true at the same time.

DOJ can drop the certification lawsuit because it no longer offers a meaningful remedy.

Investigators can continue examining the alleged recruitment scheme.

And Alaska can move toward certification while voters wait to learn whether the “Decoy Dan” story ends with criminal evidence or merely another ugly political operation that never changed the result.

For now, Peltola’s “win” is still listed by the state as unofficial.

But the federal lawsuit that threatened to block its certification is effectively over.

This is a Guest Post from our friends over at WLTReport. View the original article here.

 

Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.