Welcome to Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s New York.
The city that cannot keep violent criminals off the streets is now turning its attention to the way restaurants cook lobsters.
A new City Council proposal would ban every New York City food-service establishment from placing a live lobster, crab, or other crustacean into boiling liquid.
Yes, this is real.
JUST IN: New York City moves to ban the boiling of live lobsters, crabs, & other crustaceans. pic.twitter.com/DGVOG6K4qu
— Polymarket (@Polymarket) November 20, 2026
The official paper trail matters here.
New York City Council records show that Introduction 1188 was filed on November 19 by Council Members Oswald Feliz and Harvey Epstein and sent to the Committee on Health. No committee hearing or vote has yet been taken.
The bill remains in committee, and the legislative record lists Feliz and Epstein—not Mamdani—as its two sponsors.
The timing ties it directly to the animal-welfare campaign sweeping through Mamdani’s City Hall: it arrived the very same day the mayor signed a separate law phasing out Central Park’s horse-drawn carriage industry.
Under Intro 1188, restaurants could continue selling lobster and crab. They would simply be forbidden from putting the animals into boiling liquid while they are still alive.
The first violation would carry a $0 penalty—a formal warning. Every later violation could bring a civil fine of up to $100.
If the proposal becomes law, it would take effect 180 days later.
The text does not dictate one replacement cooking method. It leaves restaurants free to prepare crustaceans another way so long as they are not placed alive into boiling liquid.
That distinction will matter as the Health Committee decides whether the proposal advances to a hearing and a vote.
🦞 After foie gras, NYC Council takes aim at boiling lobsters alive https://t.co/VTpzUWZjNv
📸 Joe Raedle/Getty Images pic.twitter.com/ugIEFfS7Ys
— 1010 WINS on 92.3 FM (@1010WINS) November 20, 2026
Supporters insist the bill is a narrow humane-treatment measure, not an attempt to take lobster off the menu.
The sponsors argue that restaurants can kill or stun crustaceans before cooking them. Their legislation says only that a conscious animal cannot be dropped directly into the pot.
Local reporting says the sponsors cited scientific research indicating that lobsters and crabs can experience significant pain when boiled without first being stunned.
That claim is not coming out of thin air.
A peer-reviewed 2026 study in Scientific Reports found that aspirin and lidocaine reduced the escape responses of Norway lobsters exposed to an electrical shock. The researchers said the result added evidence that the animals process harmful stimuli as pain rather than merely displaying an automatic muscle reaction.
The study divided 105 lobsters into control and treatment groups and observed them before, during, and after a ten-second electrical stimulus. Untreated animals showed stronger tail-flip escape behavior, while the response dropped sharply among animals given either painkiller.
The authors argued that if the movement were only an automatic muscular reaction, analgesic drugs should not have reduced it. Their conclusion was that the response likely includes a neurological component associated with pain.
Countries including Switzerland and Norway already require lobsters to be stunned or rendered unconscious before boiling.
That is the argument for the bill.
The argument against it is just as obvious: New York’s political class keeps finding new behavior to regulate while families and small businesses deal with crime, housing costs, taxes, and an affordability crisis that City Hall has not solved.
Restaurant owners would be the ones expected to change their kitchens, train workers, and absorb another layer of compliance—however small the fine may look on paper.
And this proposal did not arrive in isolation.
Hours before the lobster story broke, Mamdani signed Romanch’s Law, which will end horse-drawn carriage rides in Central Park by June 2028.
The Associated Press reported that carriage drivers sued almost immediately after Mamdani signed the measure, arguing that the city is destroying their livelihoods without adequate protection.
The law is scheduled to end the rides by June 2028. City Hall says it will release a transition plan next April with job training, educational opportunities, and stipends, but the Transport Workers Union says those protections should have been written into the legislation itself.
The federal lawsuit argues that New York violated local procedures and unconstitutionally damaged the owners’ property interests and contracts. It names Mamdani and other city officials as defendants.
Mamdani defended that law by saying New York had changed and its laws needed to change with it.
Now the council is testing how much further that philosophy can go.
Today it is horse carriages and boiling lobsters. Tomorrow, New Yorkers are entitled to wonder which ordinary practice City Hall will decide to regulate next.
Whatever one thinks about the treatment of crustaceans, this much is clear: Mamdani-era New York is moving quickly to put government in places most people never imagined it would go.
This is a Guest Post from our friends over at WLTReport. View the original article here.







