Democratic Rep. Ro Khanna says Medicare for All would slash America’s health care bill to $4 trillion and become one of the most pro-business policies the country could adopt.

That is a breathtaking sales pitch for putting Washington in charge of nearly every medical bill in the country.

Khanna posted the claim this week as Democrats prepare to take control of Congress and the party’s left flank demands another push for single-payer health care.

Here is the number Khanna is asking Americans to accept:

The first problem is his baseline.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services says national health spending reached $5.3 trillion in 2024, not 2026. CMS projects that spending rose to $5.7 trillion in 2025 and will grow another 6.3 percent in 2026.

That means Khanna is comparing his $4 trillion promise with an old number while presenting it as the current national tab.

The second problem is more fundamental: transferring a bill does not make the bill disappear.

Premiums, employer contributions and out-of-pocket costs may be relabeled under a single-payer system, but Washington still has to collect the money. The financing arrives through federal taxes, borrowing, lower payments to doctors and hospitals, tighter benefits, or some combination of all four.

The Congressional Budget Office examined five illustrative single-payer designs and found that the result depends heavily on provider payment rates, patient cost sharing, coverage rules and long-term-care benefits. There is no honest one-line guarantee that a national system simply lands at $4 trillion.

CBO’s framework also exposes the tradeoffs hidden inside the slogan. Pay hospitals and physicians less, and the projected federal cost falls.

Expand benefits or long-term services, and it rises. Eliminate cost sharing, and demand changes again.

The agency did not endorse a single design or promise a fixed savings figure. It modeled different policy choices precisely because payment levels, utilization and covered benefits change both the federal budget and the care patients receive.

A serious proposal therefore has to identify who pays the new federal revenue, which services are covered and how aggressively Washington would cut reimbursement. Khanna’s post supplies none of those details.

ADVERTISEMENT

Vermont learned how quickly the theory collides with the tax bill.

The State of Vermont estimated that the preferred Green Mountain Care plan would require an 11.5 percent payroll tax on employers plus an income-based public premium reaching 9.5 percent for the highest earners. The report also said proposed phase-ins and exemptions meant to soften the blow were unaffordable.

Supporters can argue that those taxes replace premiums. They cannot pretend the taxes are not real, or that every family and employer would come out ahead.

The same warning applies nationally. A $4 trillion government program would be the largest social-spending commitment in American history, administered by the same federal bureaucracy already struggling with improper payments, fraud and runaway debt.

One critic put that concern bluntly:

America’s health care system is expensive, confusing and badly in need of reform. Conservatives should be willing to attack opaque pricing, hospital consolidation, anti-competitive rules and the incentives that keep patients from seeing the true price of care.

But a government monopoly is not a cost estimate.

If Khanna wants Congress to nationalize health insurance, he should show the complete tax schedule, provider cuts, benefit assumptions and enforcement machinery required to make his $4 trillion figure work.

Until then, “Medicare for All will lower costs” is a campaign slogan attached to a bill somebody else will be forced to pay.

ADVERTISEMENT

 

Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.